Supreme Court upholds quashing of Yes Bank AT-1 bond write-off
The Supreme Court has dismissed appeals, directing Yes Bank to restore Rs 8,415 crore in written-off AT-1 bonds to investors, a move that will impact the bank's capital ratios.

Yes Bank has filed a petition with the Supreme Court to review an October 15 order. That order upheld the quashing of the write-off of Rs 8,415 crore in AT-1 bonds. The legal saga began with a government-imposed moratorium on the bank in March 2020. The bank's administrator then wrote down the additional tier-1 bonds. Bondholders and their trustee challenged this action in the Bombay High Court, which ruled in their favor. The high court set aside the administrator's decision, a ruling now confirmed by the nation's top court.
Court rulings and the October 15 verdict
On October 15, the Supreme Court dismissed appeals by Yes Bank, the Reserve Bank of India, and the central government. This action upheld a Bombay High Court judgement from January 20, 2023. The high court had ruled the administrator lacked the authority to write off the bonds. It noted the final reconstruction scheme sanctioned by the government contained no clause permitting such a write-down. The Supreme Court directed Yes Bank to restore the bonds to bondholders with immediate effect. The high court's decision had initially been stayed for six weeks. The Supreme Court stated that investor risk could have been avoided if the RBI and Yes Bank had acted in accordance with the relevant Master Circular. It also questioned the actions of the RBI, the administrator, and the bank in dealing with the bonds.
Financial impact and capital ratios
Reinstating the bonds will have a direct impact on Yes Bank's capital structure. The pro forma effect on the bank's common equity tier-1 ratio, including profits, is approximately 240 basis points. The bank's capital position as of September 30 provides the baseline for this calculation.
| Capital Metric | Figure |
|---|---|
| Capital Adequacy Ratio (as of 30 Sept) | 14.5% |
| Common Equity Tier-1 Ratio (as of 30 Sept) | 13.7% |
| Pro Forma CET1 Ratio (post-reinstatement) | ~13.7% |
| Pro Forma Overall Tier 1 Ratio | ~13.7% |
Market reaction and investor representation
The market reaction to the conclusive ruling was muted. Shares of Yes Bank ended 0.3% lower on the National Stock Exchange on Friday. The decision directly affects a defined group of investors. The Yes Bank AT-1 Bond Holders Association represents between 400 and 450 affected individuals and institutions. Following the verdict, Axis Trustee Services has written to the bank seeking the restoration of the bonds and payment of all pending interest dues.
Additional tier-1 bonds are perpetual instruments banks issue to bolster their capital base. They carry higher risk but offer higher interest rates compared to traditional bonds. Regulations allow the RBI to direct a bank to cancel such bonds if it gets into trouble. In its review petition, Yes Bank seeks a hearing on whether the October 15 order suffers from any error warranting reconsideration. If the court finds merit, it will rehear the validity of the Rs 8,415 crore write-off. If not, the order directing restoration will stand. The bank is now required to restore the bonds to bondholders with immediate effect.





